Select notes to view   |  Currently Viewing: Note 31 – Fair value hierarchy
31 Financial instruments
 

The group’s objective in using financial instruments is to reduce the uncertainty over future cash flows arising principally as a result of commodity price, currency and interest rate fluctuations. The use of derivatives for the hedging of firm commitments against commodity price, foreign currency and interest rate exposures is permitted in accordance with group policies, which have been approved by the board of directors. Where significant finance is taken out, this is approved at board meetings.

The foreign exchange contracts outstanding at year end are marked-to-market at the prevailing closing spot rate.

The group finances its operations through a combination of retained surpluses, bank borrowings and long-term loans.

The group borrows short-term funds with fixed or floating rates of interest through a subsidiary company, Tiger Consumer Brands Limited.

The main risks arising from the group’s financial instruments are, in order of priority, procurement risk, foreign currency risk, interest rate risk, liquidity risk and credit risk as detailed in the following notes.

31.1 Procurement risk (commodity price risk)
 

Commodity price risk arises from the group being subject to raw material price fluctuations caused by supply conditions, weather, economic conditions and other factors. The strategic raw materials acquired by the group include wheat, maize, rice, oats and sorghum.

The group uses commodity futures and options contracts or other derivative instruments to reduce the volatility of commodity input prices of strategic raw materials. These derivative contracts are only taken out to match an underlying physical requirement for the raw material. The group does not write naked derivative contracts.

The group has developed a comprehensive risk management process to facilitate, control and to monitor these risks. The procurement of raw materials takes place in terms of specific mandates given by the executive management. Position statements are prepared on a monthly basis and these are monitored by management and compared to the mandates.

The board has approved and monitors this risk management process, inclusive of documented treasury policies, counterparty limits, controlling and reporting structures.

At year end the exposure to derivative contracts relating to strategic raw materials is as follows:

  Derivative contracts expiring
within 0 – 3 months
Group
(R’million)
Unrealised
profit at
30 September
Hedged
value
2020    
Maize and wheat    
   Futures (1,5) 114,2
2019    
Maize and wheat    
   Futures (4,3) 280,9

Commodity price sensitivity analysis

The following table details the group’s sensitivity to a 10% increase and decrease in the price of wheat, rice, maize and sorghum, excluding the impact of cash flow hedges. A +10% increase would result in an outflow whereas a -10% decrease would result in an inflow.

The 10% stringency is the sensitivity rate used when reporting the commodity price risk internally to key management personnel and represents management’s assessment of the possible change in the relevant commodity prices.

  Profit/(loss) before tax Profit/(loss) after tax
Group
(R’million)
2020
(+10%)/-10%
2019
(+10%)/-10%
2020
(+10%)/-10%
2019
(+10%)/-10%
Milling and Baking 43,3 42,5 31,2 30,6
Other grains 254,3 240,6 183,1 173,2
Other* 45,0 61,3 32,4 44,1
Total 342,6 344,4 246,7 247,9
* Other includes, tomato paste, sugar, soya and sundry items.

Commodity price sensitivity is not applicable to the company.

31.2 Foreign currency risk
 

The group enters into various types of foreign exchange contracts as part of the management of its foreign exchange exposures arising from its current and anticipated business activities.

As the group operates in various countries and undertakes transactions denominated in foreign currencies, exposures to foreign currency fluctuations arise. Exchange rate exposures on transactions are managed within approved policy parameters utilising forward exchange contracts or other derivative financial instruments in conjunction with external consultants who provide financial services to group companies as well as contributing to the management of the financial risks relating to the group’s operations.

The group does not hold foreign exchange contracts in respect of foreign borrowings, as its intention is to repay these from its foreign income stream or subsequent divestment of its interest in the operation. Foreign exchange differences relating to investments, net of their related borrowings, are reported as translation differences in the group’s net other comprehensive income until the disposal of the net investment, at which time exchange differences are recycled through profit or loss.

Forward exchange contracts are entered into to cover import exposures and export exposures, on an individual currency basis. The fair value is determined using the applicable foreign exchange spot rates at 30 September 2020.

The exposure and concentration of foreign currency risk is included in the table below.

Group
(R’million)
South
African
rand
US
dollar
Pound
sterling
Euro Other* Total
2020            
Financial assets            
Accounts receivable 3 658,5 107,1 40,2 20,7 171,5 3 998,0
Cash and cash equivalents 651,8 685,3 9,9 29,8 413,2 1 790,0
Financial liabilities            
Borrowings (335,2) (3,0) (338,2)
Accounts payable (4 583,4) (23,4) (67,0) (21,5) (227,3) (4 922,6)
2019            
Financial assets            
Accounts receivable 3 512,7 136,5 17,5 30,1 257,1 3 953,9
Cash and cash equivalents 1 274,0 105,6 17,7 7,9 318,7 1 723,9
Financial liabilities            
Borrowings (519,0) (519,0)
Accounts payable (4 625,4) (128,4) 3,7 10,8 (313,5) (5 052,8)
* Other includes the Australian dollar, Canadian dollar, Japanese yen, Swiss franc, New Zealand dollar and Cameroon franc.

The following spot rates were used to translate financial instruments denominated in foreign currency:

Group Assets 2020
Liabilities
Average Assets 2020
Liabilities
Average
US dollar 16,79 16,82 16,81 15,15 15,15 15,15
Pound sterling 21,58 21,63 21,61 18,65 18,66 18,66
Euro 19,63 19,68 19,66 16,51 16,52 16,52

Forward exchange contracts outstanding at the reporting date all fall due within six months. A summary of forward exchange contract positions bought to settle group foreign liabilities and sold to settle group foreign assets is shown below.

    2020     2019  
Group Foreign 
currency 
(in millions)
Average
rate
Rand 
(in millions)
Foreign 
currency 
(in millions)
Average
rate
Rand 
(in millions)
Foreign currency sold            
US dollar 4,8 16,19 81,0 9,5 14,51 141,5
Pound sterling 1,8 20,31 39,1 0,7 18,10 12,6
Euro 1,9 18,40 37,9 3,8 16,51 63,5
Other currencies     20,4     5,7
Foreign currency purchased            
US dollar 15,4 15,96 259,8 37,8 14,73 550,0
Pound sterling 2,0 19,80 44,0 3,9 18,26 72,0
Euro 5,8 18,27 114,8 8,6 16,59 144,5
Other currencies     2,3     8,6
Unhedged foreign currency monetary assets            
US dollar 9,3 16,79 156,6 13,8 15,15 209,6
Pound sterling 2,3 21,58 50,1 0,9 18,65 16,3
Euro 2,6 19,63 50,5 2,0 16,51 32,5
Other currencies     55,5     16,1
Unhedged foreign currency monetary liabilities            
US dollar 0,1 16,82 2,0 0,4 15,15 6,8
Euro 19,68 0,4 0,1 16,52 1,0
Other currencies     0,1     0,2

Cash flow hedges

At 30 September 2020, the group had foreign exchange contracts outstanding designated as hedges of future purchases from suppliers outside South Africa for which the group has firm commitments or highly likely forecast transactions.

A summary of these contracts are:

    2020     2019  
Group Foreign 
currency 
(in millions)
Average
rate
Rand 
(in millions)
Foreign 
currency 
(in millions)
Average
rate
Rand 
(in millions)
Foreign currency bought            
US dollar 1,5 16,44 25,2 34,8 14,89 517,9
Euro 0,3 19,00 5,8 2,7 16,53 45,4
Pound sterling 0,6 20,83 12,9 0,8 18,42 13,9
Other currencies     0,8     1,3

The terms of the forward currency contracts have been negotiated to match the terms of the commitments.

The cash flow hedge of expected future sales was assessed to be effective and an unrealised profit of R0,5 million (2019: R2,4 million) relating to the hedging instrument included in other comprehensive income.

Timing of cash flows relating to foreign currency is as follows:

  Group
Foreign currency (in millions) 1 – 6 months
US dollar 1,5
Pound sterling 0,6
Euro 0,3
Other currencies 2,2

These are expected to affect the income statement in the following year.

During the year R16,8 million (2019: R8,2 million) was released from other comprehensive income and included in the carrying amount of the non-financial asset or liability (highly probable forecast transactions).

There are no forecast transactions for which hedge accounting was previously used but is no longer expected to occur.

Ineffective hedges to the value of R1,6 million (2019: R0,4 million) have been recognised in profit or loss.

Cash flow hedges

At 30 September 2020, the group had foreign exchange contracts outstanding designated as hedges of future sales to customers outside South Africa for which the group has firm commitments or highly likely forecast transactions.

A summary of these contracts are:

    2020     2019  
Group Foreign 
currency 
(in millions)
Average
rate
Rand
(in millions)
Foreign 
currency 
(in millions)
Average
rate
Rand 
(in millions)
Foreign currency sold            
US dollar 16,44 4,5 14,89 67,1
Euro 0,7 19,00 12,9 16,53
Pound sterling 1,7 20,83 35,4 0,5 18,42 8,7
Australian dollar 0,1 12,41 0,9 10,07 0,3

The terms of the forward currency contracts have been negotiated to match the terms of the commitments.

The cash flow hedge of expected future sales was assessed to be effective and an unrealised profit of R0,5 million (2019: unrealised profit R2,4 million) relating to the hedging instrument included in other comprehensive income.

Timing of cash flows relating to foreign currency is as follows:

  Group
Foreign currency (in millions) 1 – 6 months
US dollar
Pound sterling 1,7
Euro 0,7
Canadian dollar 0,7
Australian dollar 0,1

These are expected to affect the income statement in the following year.

During the year R4,9 million (2019: R8,8 million) was released from other comprehensive income and included in the carrying amount of the non-financial asset or liability (highly probable forecast transactions).

There are no forecast transactions for which hedge accounting was previously used but is no longer expected to occur.

Ineffective hedges to the value of R2,0 million (2019: R0,9 million) have been recognised in profit or loss.

Foreign currency sensitivity

The following table details the group’s and company’s sensitivity to a 10% weakening/strengthening in the ZAR against the respective foreign currencies.

The sensitivity analysis includes only material outstanding foreign currency denominated monetary items as detailed in the table above and adjusts their translation at the reporting date for a 10% change in foreign currency rates. A positive number indicates an increase in profit or loss and other comprehensive income where the ZAR weakens against the relevant currency.

  Other comprehensive income Profit or loss Equity
(R’million) 2020 2019 2020 2019 2020 2019
Group            
USD +10% (2,6) (44,0) (89,2) 66,7 (66,1) 16,4
USD -10% 2,6 44,0 89,2 (66,7) 66,1 (16,4)
Pound sterling +10% 2,3 (0,5) 3,8 (14,2) 4,4 (10,6)
Pound sterling -10% (2,3) 0,5 (3,8) 14,2 (4,4) 10,6
EUR +10% 0,8 (4,7) (25,6) 19,3 (17,8) 10,5
EUR -10% (0,8) 4,7 25,6 (19,3) 17,8 (10,5)
Other +10% 0,9 (0,1) (81,8) 17,8 (58,2) 12,7
Other -10% (0,9) 0,1 81,8 (17,8) 58,2 (12,7)
Total +10% 1,4 (49,3) (192,8) 89,6 (137,7) 29,0
Total -10% (1,4) 49,3 192,8 (89,6) 137,7 (29,0)
Company            
USD +10% 1,1 0,8
USD -10% (1,1) (0,8)
Other +10% 9,4 6,7 6,8 4,8
Other -10% (9,4) (6,7) (6,8) (4,8)
Total +10% 9,4 7,8 6,8 5,6
Total -10% (9,4) (7,8) (6,8) (5,6)

Forex currency sensitivity on associates

The following table details the group’s sensitivity to a 5% weakening/strengthening in the ZAR against the respective foreign currencies in which the associates operate.

  Other comprehensive income
Group
(R’million)
2020 2019
Chilean peso +5% (106,2) (97,5)
Chilean peso -5% 117,3 103,7
Zimbabwean dollar +5% 4,4 (5,2)
Zimbabwean dollar -5% (4,4) 4,6
Nigerian naira +5% (11,8) (10,8)
Nigerian naira -5% 1,2 12,0
Total +5% (113,6) (113,5)
Total -5% 114,1 120,3
31.3 Interest rate risk management
 

Interest rate risk results from the cash flow and financial performance uncertainty arising from interest rate fluctuations.

Financial assets and liabilities affected by interest rate fluctuations include bank and cash deposits as well as bank borrowings. At the reporting date, the group cash deposits were accessible immediately or had maturity dates up to six months. The interest rates earned on these deposits closely approximate the market rates prevailing.

Interest rate sensitivity

The sensitivity analysis addresses only the floating interest rate exposure emanating from the net cash position. The interest rate exposure has been calculated with the stipulated change taking place at the beginning of the financial year and held constant throughout the reporting period.

If interest rates had increased/(decreased) by 1% and all other variables were held constant, the profit for the year ended would decrease/(increase) as detailed in the table below due to the use of the variable interest rates applicable to the long-term borrowings and short-term borrowings. The fixed interest rate on the borrowings would not affect the financial performance. Any gain or loss would be unrealised and consequently the notional impact is not presented.

(R’million) 2020 2019
Group    
Profit/(loss) before tax    
ZAR borrowings    
(+1%)/-1% (14,3) (10,6)
Foreign borrowings    
(+1%)/-1% 0,4
Profit/(loss) after tax    
ZAR borrowings    
(+1%)/-1% (10,3) (7,6)
Foreign borrowings    
(+1%)/-1% 0,3
Company    
Profit before tax    
Cash deposits    
+1%/(-1%) 4,2 9,9
Profit after tax    
Cash deposits    
+1%/(-1%) 3,0 7,1
31.4 Liquidity risk management
 

Liquidity risk arises from the seasonal fluctuations in short-term borrowing positions. A material and sustained shortfall in cash flows could undermine investor confidence and restrict the group’s ability to raise funds.

The group manages its liquidity risk by monitoring weekly cash flows and ensuring that adequate cash is available or borrowing facilities maintained. In terms of the memorandum of incorporation, the group’s borrowing powers are unlimited. The group has no significant concentration of liquidity risk with any other single counterparty.

The group’s liquidity exposure is represented by the aggregate balance of financial liabilities as indicated in the categorisation table in note 31.7.

Contractual maturity for non-derivative financial liabilities

The following tables detail the group’s and company’s remaining contractual maturity for non-derivative financial liabilities.

The tables have been drawn-up based on the undiscounted cash flows of financial liabilities based on the earliest date on which the group and company will be required to pay. The table includes both interest and principal cash flows. The “finance charge” column represents the possible future cash flows attributable to the instrument included in the maturity analysis, which are not included in the carrying amount of the financial liability.

(R’million) Carrying
amount
Finance
charge
0 – 6
months
7 – 12
months
1 – 5
years
> 5
years
Group            
2020            
Trade and other payables 4 509,6 4 509,6
Lease liability*# 336,2 (40,8) 94,4 62,9 206,2 13,5
Liabilities held for sale 303,9 (0,4) 304,3
Total 5 149,7 (41,2) 4 908,3 62,9 206,2 13,5
2019            
Trade and other payables 4 504,6 4 504,6
Borrowings (long and short term)# 0,5 0,5
Liabilities held for sale 149,2 149,2
Total 4 654,3 4 654,3
Company            
2020            
Trade and other payables 27,0 27,0
Intergroup loan accounts 32,1 32,1
Total 59,1 59,1
2019            
Trade and other payables 27,8 27,8
Total 27,8 27,8
* IFRS 16 was adopted by the group in the current reporting period.
# Excludes bank overdrafts of R2,0 million (2019: R518,5 million) and cash of R1 790,0 million (2019: R1 723,9 million). These are repayable on demand and subject to annual review.

Refer to note 25.1 and 26.3 for disclosure relating to lease commitments.

31.5 Credit risk management
 

Group

Credit risk arises from the risk that a counterparty may default or not meet its obligations timeously. The group limits its counterparty exposure arising from financial instruments by only dealing with well-established institutions of high credit standing. The group does not expect any counterparties to fail to meet their obligations given their high credit ratings.

Credit risk in respect of the group’s customer base is controlled by the application of credit limits and credit monitoring procedures. Certain significant receivables are monitored on a daily basis. Where appropriate, credit guarantee insurance is obtained.

The group’s credit exposure, in respect of its customer base, is represented by the net aggregate balance of amounts receivable. Concentrations of credit risk are disclosed in note 19.

Company

Credit risk exposure at 30 September 2020 relating to guarantees amounted to R3,5 million (2019: R4,1 million). Refer to note 30.

31.6 Capital management
 

The primary objective of the company and group’s capital management is to ensure that it maintains a strong credit rating and healthy capital ratios in order to support its business and maximise shareholder value.

The company and group manages its capital structure, calculated as equity plus net debt, and makes adjustments to it, in light of changes in economic conditions. To maintain or adjust the capital structure, the company and group may adjust the dividend payment to shareholders, return capital to shareholders, issue new shares or increase or decrease levels of debt. No changes were made in the objectives, policies or processes during the years ended 30 September 2020 and 30 September 2019.

The company and group monitor capital using a gearing ratio, which is net debt divided by total equity. The company and group targets a long-term gearing ratio of 30% to 40%, except when major investments are made where this target may be exceeded.

Company     Group
2020 2019   (R’million) 2020 2019
(175,6) (67,4)   Cash and cash equivalents (1 790,0) (1 723,9)
  Long-term borrowings 197,2
  Short-term borrowings 141,0 519,0
(175,6) (67,4)   Net cash (1 451,8) (1 204,9)
7 986,7 8 697,9   Total equity 15 787,4 15 407,5
(2,2) (0,8)   Net cash to equity (%) (9,2) (7,8)
31.7 Categorisation of financial assets and liabilities
 
Group
(R’million)
Financial
assets
amortised
cost
Financial
assets at
fair value
through OCI
Other
liabilities
amortised
cost
Financial
instruments
at fair value
through
profit or loss
Non-
financial
items
Total
book
value
2020            
Remaining assets 113,3 16 096,9 16 210,2
Other investments 83,0 300,7 383,7
Loans 30,3 30,3
Trade and other receivables 3 582,9 3,0 333,9 3 919,8
Cash and cash equivalents 1 790,0 1 790,0
Total 5 599,5 300,7 3,0 16 430,8 22 334,0
Shareholders’ equity and remaining liabilities (17 486,2) (17 486,2)
Long-term borrowings (197,2) (197,2)
Trade and other payables (3 427,6) (16,1) (1 065,9) (4 509,6)
Short-term borrowings (141,0) (141,0)
Total (3 765,8) (16,1) (18 552,1) (22 334,0)
2019            
Remaining assets 15 987,7 15 987,7
Other investments 78,2 350,8 429,0
Loans 28,6 28,6
Trade and other receivables 3 725,7 27,0 235,1 3 987,8
Cash and cash equivalents 1 723,9 1 723,9
Assets classified as held for sale 1,2 22,3 23,5
Total 5 557,6 350,8 27,0 16 245,1 22 180,5
Shareholders’ equity and remaining liabilities (17 007,7) (17 007,7)
Trade and other payables (3 601,3) (5,2) (898,1) (4 504,6)
Short-term borrowings (519,0) (519,0)
Liabilities directly associated with assets classified as held for sale (149,2) (149,2)
Total (4 120,3) (5,2) (18 055,0) (22 180,5)

Refer to the accounting policies for further details on the above classifications.

Company
(R’million)
Financial
assets
amortised
cost
Financial
assets at
fair value
through OCI
Other
liabilities
amortised
cost
Financial
instruments
at fair value
through
profit or loss
Non-
financial
items
Total
book
value
2020            
Remaining assets 2 604,9 2 604,9
Other investments 22,5 2 186,2 2 208,7
Loans# 3 058,1 3 058,1
Trade and other receivables 1,6 2,1 3,7
Cash and cash equivalents 175,6 175,6
Total 3 235,3 22,5 2 186,2 2 607,0 8 051,0
Shareholders’ equity and remaining liabilities   (7 991,9) (7 991,9)
Trade and other payables (27,0) (27,0)
Loans# (32,1) (32,1)
Total (32,1) (27,0) (7 991,9) (8 051,0)
2019            
Remaining assets 2 819,6 2 819,6
Other investments 23,5   2 166,2   2 189,7
Loans# 2 956,3 680,1 3 636,4
Trade and other receivables 15,3 2,5 17,8
Cash and cash equivalents 67,4 67,4
Total 3 039,0 23,5 2 846,3 2 822,1 8 730,9
Shareholders’ equity and remaining liabilities (8 703,1) (8 703,1)
Trade and other payables (27,8) (27,8)
Total (27,8) (8 703,1) (8 730,9)
# Includes amounts owed by/(to) subsidiaries.

Refer to the accounting policies for further details on the above classifications.

31.8 Fair value hierarchy
 

Financial instruments are normally held by the group until they close out in the normal course of business. The fair values of the group’s financial instruments, which principally comprise put, call and futures positions with SAFEX, forward exchange contracts and JSE-listed investments, approximate their carrying values. The maturity profile of these financial instruments fall due within 12 months.

There are no significant differences between carrying values and fair values of financial assets and liabilities.

Trade and other receivables, amounts owed by subsidiaries, investments and loans and trade and other payables carried on the statement of financial position approximate the fair values.

Long-term and short-term borrowings are measured at amortised cost using the effective interest rate method and the carrying amounts approximate their fair value.

The group used the following hierarchy for determining and disclosing the fair value of financial instruments by valuation technique:

Level 1: Quoted (unadjusted) prices in active markets for identical assets or liabilities.

Level 2: Other techniques for which all inputs which have a significant effect on the recorded fair value are observable, either directly or indirectly.

Level 3: Techniques which use inputs which have a significant effect on the recorded fair value that are not based on observable market data.

As at 30 September, the group held the following financial instruments measured at fair value:

  2020 2019
(R’million) Level 1 Level 2 Level 3** Total Level 1 Level 2 Level 3** Total
Group                
Assets measured at fair value                
Financial assets                
Other investments 292,3 0,4 8,0 300,7 343,0 0,3 7,5 350,8
Derivatives 3,0 3,0 27,0 27,0
Liabilities                
Derivatives (16,1) (16,1) (5,2) (5,2)
Company                
Assets measured at fair value                
Financial assets                
Other investments 2 200,3 0,4 8,0 2 208,7 2 181,9 0,3 7,5 2 189,7
Loans*** 680,1   680,1
** The value of the investment in Group Risk Holdings is based on Tiger Brand’s proportionate share of the net asset value of the company. There are no other significant inputs that are used in the valuation and any changes in these inputs would not result in a significant fair value change.
*** The fair value of these loans are assessed on returns based on the listed investment held by the related party.